Motaleat-e-Taghribi Mazaheb-e-Eslami (Proximity Studies of Islamic Denominations) (Foroughe Vahdat)

Motaleat-e-Taghribi Mazaheb-e-Eslami (Proximity Studies of Islamic Denominations) (Foroughe Vahdat)

A comparative study and analysis of the views of Ali Abdul Raziq al-Masri and Allama Javadi Amoli on the Islamic government

Articles in Press

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
seyed mohammad nagheb 1
mohammad farahani 2
mohammadreza fazeli 3
1 Associate Professor, Holy Quran University of Sciences and Education
2 Assistant Professor, Holy Quran University of Sciences and Education
3 PhD student in Natural Interpretation, University of Holy Quran Sciences and Education
10.22034/mtmi.2026.532121.1871
Abstract
Among Muslim thinkers, "Ali Abdul Raziq Al-Masri", as the pioneer of the theory of separation of religion from politics, claims that there is no evidence or pseudo-evidence for government or politics in the Quran. In this article, the aim is to analyze and criticize the aforementioned claim based on the opinions of the great commentator of the Islamic world, Allamah Javadi Amoli. The method used in this research is descriptive-analytical and data collection in a documentary library manner. The results obtained show that Ali Abdul Raziq's view on the Islamic government is an unreasonable view and a kind of interpretation of the verses of the Quran. Also, religion is not separate from politics, but they are necessary and necessary for each other, and the intervention of divine prophets in social affairs was a duty based on divine teachings, which itself shows the intervention of religion in all matters of the world, and also the government is a necessity that implements the social and legal rules of religion in society.
Keywords
Islamic government
Ali Abdul Raziq Al-Masri
Tasnim commentary
religion
politics
Motaleat-e-Taghribi Mazaheb-e-Eslami (Proximity Studies of Islamic Denominations) (Foroughe Vahdat)

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 08 June 2026